Avg rating:
Your rating:
Total ratings: 1419
Length: 2:38
Plays (last 30 days): 2
I'm gonna leave you honey now
Well that train passed by when you lay sleeping
I'm gonna write you a letter on a dusty boxcar wall
The only two things a gambler needs
Are a suitcase and a trunk
And the only time that he's satisfied
Is when he's on the drunk
I once loved a boy in Cincinnati
I loved a boy in sunny Tennessee
Well a city boy will fill your heart with sadness
But a country boy's as good as he can be
That video was clever, hilarious, revealing, and sly all at once.
Rate it an 8 for effort, and a 2 for content.
Hilarious.
Thank goodness for small blessings. Decent food, awful weather, and absolutely no city identity. The only town in the USA to be more dissolute than LA - the lack of charm is astounding.
It's just bidness.
(iTunes calls it Letters To Sinners & Strangers --big difference)
it's not that I hate it but I'll be glad when it's over
I like it, especialy on this boring rainy day.
I bet day tripper knows where to take that train.
I still need the gambler
Agreed. I'll listen to this over any of the FM trash that passes for country these days. Look for the YouTube video where they splice six "country" hits into one song, then play them all simultaneously. Hysterical!
found it..... here. and to be honest, thats enough of that stuff for a few months.
Generic? Nah. Kinda traditional, rootsy, Johnny Cash, Patsy Kline. Y'know, basically *musical*.
Generic is musically empty garbage on "Today's Country" radio, and WAY TOO F*CKING MANY stores' & malls' house systems.
Agreed. I'll listen to this over any of the FM trash that passes for country these days. Look for the YouTube video where they splice six "country" hits into one song, then play them all simultaneously. Hysterical!
Generic? Nah. Kinda traditional, rootsy, Johnny Cash, Patsy Kline. Y'know, basically *musical*.
Generic is musically empty garbage on "Today's Country" radio, and WAY TOO F*CKING MANY stores' & malls' house systems.
Good ear-dog
Palmer;
This album and artist are both, individually, true hidden treasures...
I like her voice, lyrics, arrangement and whole album...and all her others as well.
She has a big future, if she wishes. A friend recommended "Jewel" and I thought of this artist... I misjudged... Yuch....
This is real woman with real feelings and thoughts... Not a child wishing or pretending...
So.... Yeah, I like it/her both
PalmerDA wrote:
Thank goodness for small blessings. Decent food, awful weather, and absolutely no city identity. The only town in the USA to be more dissolute than LA - the lack of charm is astounding.
Spending a week in New York City does not scratch the surface. Come visit for a month or two and bounce around the country. You'll be amazed - and you're always welcome.
Amen, Businessgypsy. New York is not the same as Atlanta; neither are the same as Miami, nor San Francisco, nor Chicago, nor New Orleans; and nowhere in the world is like Houston.
Lest we forget, the vast majority of our nation is comprised of small towns and rural areas. (I'm looking straight at you, South Carolina, my beautiful schizo homeland!)
Both songs have standard, minor-key, folk progressions, and the chord progressions and melodies of the two songs are different. I'm not sure if "straight-up copy" is a fair assessment.
Good guitar work.
For what its worth, All fruit is "techically female," being the ovary of the plant.
So it isn't weird if I have naughty thoughts about banana peels?
On other days it's okay, but not today... *sigh*
I'll shut up now...
Lots of good female country singers. Just gotta work a bit to find em...but the ones who make it last decades,,, Thanks to RP I've started digging more into Emmy Lou Harris...she's been good for decades...and stays good... But she was so consistent and seldom erratic of experimenting I grew blase...Now I'm finding her all over again... and Same for Rita Coolidge... I had forgotten how wonderful her voice is... The famale voice says things that a make voice can never convey. Few of the newer female singers let the voice work the magic on the male psyche... They work too hard to be perfect... For me a softer, personal sound hoks me in... Perfection is boring... I want personality and personal relationship... dark night, moon, bit of wind and scattered rain...and soft female voice... OK... That's me. And that takes time. Not a hit and run... no 25 second sample... Lots of good music around... Keep searching.
Stingray wrote:
10.000...? Or 100.000 already?
Not that I generally dislike "girls" singing. Absolutely not!
But too many are too simelar!
Bill's the true "girli-man" - he's completely in true LOVE with most of them!
America, it seems, is generally much softer when it comes to (Rock-)music,
way more than Europe, especially England!
STINGRAY
I wonder about people who buy only songs and those decisions based on a single hearing. Me-? I buy the CDs and even back/used music then let the artist's talent envelope me... Sometimes it works-someties not. But I still like to find, discover and understand who and why I like or dislike... She is very good. A long career is ahead-unless things go sideways...
michelle shocked's L&N don't stop here no more
to eilen jewell's chug a chug dusty boxcar wall
For what its worth, All fruit is "techically female," being the ovary of the plant.
Yeah. Redundant! Redundant! Redundant!
For what its worth, All fruit is "techically female," being the ovary of the plant.
If every singer who covered a song had to have experienced what the original songwriter experienced there'd many orders of magnitude fewer covers produced.
way more than Europe, especially England!...
Spending a week in New York City does not scratch the surface. Come visit for a month or two and bounce around the country. You'll be amazed - and you're always welcome.
Uh, at home and clean?
It's called 'homage'.
10.000...? Or 100.000 already?
Not that I generally dislike "girls" singing. Absolutely not!
But too many are too simelar!
Bill's the true "girli-man" - he's completely in true LOVE with most of them!
America, it seems, is generally much softer when it comes to (Rock-)music,
way more than Europe, especially England!
STINGRAY
Never been to Nashville have you?
10.000...? Or 100.000 already?
Not that I generally dislike "girls" singing. Absolutely not!
But too many are too simelar!
Bill's the true "girli-man" - he's completely in true LOVE with most of them!
America, it seems, is generally much softer when it comes to (Rock-)music,
way more than Europe, especially England!
STINGRAY
25% of all your ratings are at 7, fred. There are other options, you know!
True enough. 7 is my default for anything good. In this case an upgrade is deserved. 7 => 8
Yea, some Slaid Cleaves would be good. I just checked the library and it looks like one song (Broke Down) got some play in 2004-05 but not since. Even had a 7.1 rating which isn't too bad.
So nice you're playing some Eilen Jewell, of course it's sad to see bile driven, purist pundits having to lob what ever insults they can muster, but "re-makes" aside I'm pretty sure I've been checkin' since I saw her play here in town last year, and not until 'now', have I seen any of her stuff here at RP. I was thinking about uploading some songs but looks like you've got a start. But in seeing that yet another cover was chosen off her new one"Sea of Tears"? with (Shakin All Over) . I suspect the "re-make police" will be all over that one too. Her new one has some nice original stuff too hope to see them on here too. In looking over her RP info there is more favorable stuff with the song "Where They Never Say Your Name" This looks currently to be the only orignal? But as folks were saying with that, one "she's good" and I might add...getting better... I must also argree with the "Jerry Miller on guitar" part too. Luv that 60's surfer type guitar work lol...
Did Eric Andersen write Dusty Boxcar Wall? There may be an older version that she's copying. Sort of like there are more than a dozen songs with "sun's gonna shine on my backdoor someday." it's just the nature of roots music.
Lyrics aren't sacrosanct. I've never heard the original so can't compare, but looking at the two versions of the lyrics below I can't see what the problem is. She's rejigged the lyrics to fit her gender, and has kept the sense of the song's message. Some folk are a tad too precious about 'classics'. I rather like this effort, quite evocative, though I couldn't see someone as waiflike and vulnerable-looking as herself riding freight trains. 7 from the Nottingham jury.
25% of all your ratings are at 7, fred. There are other options, you know!
How about the Irish rating for any English entry in Eurovision, which is what this abortion merits?
Well, see there's the problem. This doesn't add anything to the original and sounds like someone doing karaoke who forgot the lyrics and starts making stuff up to avoid being booed off stage. Calling this weak is being generous. It's a hack job.
Lyrics aren't sacrosanct. I've never heard the original so can't compare, but looking at the two versions of the lyrics below I can't see what the problem is. She's rejigged the lyrics to fit her gender, and has kept the sense of the song's message. Some folk are a tad too precious about 'classics'. I rather like this effort, quite evocative, though I couldn't see someone as waiflike and vulnerable-looking as herself riding freight trains. 7 from the Nottingham jury.
This is nice. It's been 40 years, right? Get over it, this DOES sound different.
Hmm. I'm not sure I agree with this and others below. First, there's no rule that sez you can't write new lyrics to a song, especially if what you write adds something to the listener's understanding of what the writer intends—after all, that's what it's all about, yes? No one (well, almost no one) rags on Dylan or ragged on Led Zep when they did the same thing, right? And lifting the verse from "House..." could just as well be an homage as a rip. I'd like to see how she treats the credits in the liner notes to the CD, which I do not have. Otherwise, it's a pretty nifty rendition.
Well, see there's the problem. This doesn't add anything to the original and sounds like someone doing karaoke who forgot the lyrics and starts making stuff up to avoid being booed off stage. Calling this weak is being generous. It's a hack job.
Hmm. I'm not sure I agree with this and others below. First, there's no rule that sez you can't write new lyrics to a song, especially if what you write adds something to the listener's understanding of what the writer intends—after all, that's what it's all about, yes? No one (well, almost no one) rags on Dylan or ragged on Led Zep when they did the same thing, right? And lifting the verse from "House..." could just as well be an homage as a rip. I'd like to see how she treats the credits in the liner notes to the CD, which I do not have. Otherwise, it's a pretty nifty rendition.
Eric Andersen - Dusty Boxcar Wall
Chorus:
I’m going away my baby,
I’m gonna leave you pretty gal
For a train passed by while you lay sleeping
I’ll write you a letter on a dusty boxcar wall
I once had a love in old Kentucky
I once had a love in sunny Tennessee
But a New York gal brought me pain and sadness
Now I’m here as lonely as I can be
Chorus
City women bring you grief and sorrow
Country girls are as sweet as they can be
City women are as cold as they are shallow
But a country girl’s love is as deep as the deep blue sea
Chorus
Oh when I die and go to heaven
That’ll be tha last train ride I’ll ever see
They’ll put a silver spike upon my gravestone
And my casket beneath a weeping willow tree
——————————————-
Compare that to:
——————————————
Eilen Jewell - Dusty Boxcar Wall
Well, I’m goin’ away, my baby
I’m gonna leave you, honey, now
Well, that train passed by when you lay sleepin’
I’m gonna write you a letter on a dusty boxcar wall
Well, the only two things a gambler needs
Are a suitcase and a trunk
And the only time that he’s satisfied
Is when he’s on the drunk
And I’m goin’ away, my baby
I’m gonna leave you, honey, now
Well, that train passed by when you lay sleepin’
I’m gonna write you a letter on a dusty boxcar wall
I once loved a boy in Cincinnati
I loved a boy in sunny Tennessee
Well, a city boy will fill your heart with sadness
But a country boy’s as good as he can be
And I’m goin’ away, my baby
I’m gonna leave you, honey, now
Well, that train passed by when you lay sleepin’
I’m gonna write you a letter on a dusty boxcar wall
I’m gonna write you a letter on a dusty boxcar wall
I’m gonna write you a letter on a dusty boxcar wall
——————————————
Eric Andersen's Dusty Box Car Wall was released in 1964. Not sure what Eilen as trying to add with the House of the Rising Sun verse.
I think I would rather hear the original...
and the only time that he's satisfied is when he's on a drunk".
She stole those lyrics right out of "The House of the Rising Sun"
I loved a boy in sunny Tennessee
A city boy will fill your heart with sadness
but a country boy's as good as he can be
You said it, sister.
I believe it was written by Eric Andersen.
Rarely hear them outside of my collection. Great sounds! Thanks!
ps their new album is great!